Beta Readers, Book Comps and Barley's Cupcake Crisis

Writers With Wrinkles

Send us a text

In episode 37 of Writers With Wrinkles, co-hosts Beth McMullen and Lisa Schmid answer listener questions about writing, with a focus on the differences between beta readers and critique partners, how to find critique partners, and advice on book comps for queries. Lisa also offers a PSA on dogs eating too many cupcakes.

Key Discussion Points:

• Beta Readers vs. Critique Partners:
  Beth and Lisa explain that beta readers provide general reader feedback, focusing on how engaging a manuscript is, while critique partners offer more technical, writer-focused critiques. Beta readers are typically not writers, while critique partners should be.
• How to Find Critique Partners:
  They discuss several avenues for finding critique partners, including professional organizations like SCBWI, Facebook groups, and writing communities. They stress the importance of finding the right fit and being open to change if the partnership isn’t productive.
• Book Comps in Queries:
  The hosts advise on how to select appropriate comparative titles for book pitches, emphasizing that comps should be from within the last two years to reflect current market trends. They suggest using older favorites as a starting point for finding more recent comps.
• Barley the Dog & the Box of Cupcakes:
  Lisa recounts how her dog, Barley, ate a box of chocolate cupcakes, prompting her to call a pet poison hotline, which offers critical advice to pet owners in similar situations.

Conclusion:

The episode provides actionable advice for aspiring writers, helping them understand the critical role beta readers and critique partners play in the manuscript development process. Beth and Lisa emphasize the importance of feedback in refining a book and navigating the publishing landscape. They also prepare listeners for the next episode, featuring literary agent Amy Nielsen.

Mentioned Links:

• SCBWI (Society of Children's Book Writers and Illustrators)
• Mystery Writers of America
• Pet Poison Helpline

Support the show

Subscribe
Visit the Website
Twitter: @BethandLisaPod
Insta: @WritersWithWrinkles
Writers with Wrinkles Link Tree for more!

Chương

1. Navigating Writers' Feedback and Support (00:00:00)

2. Finding Critique Partners and Comps (00:12:23)